Madras High Court Rules: Accused Can't Claim Default Bail Due to Missing CCTV Footage or Call Records in Police Reports
The Madras High Court ruled that missing CCTV footage and call records do not allow an accused to claim default bail if a police report is timely filed. This decision clarifies the scope of statutory rights under the BNSS Act, influencing criminal law proceedings across India.
- By
- BailNow Research Team
- Published
- Reading time
- 6 min read

On this page
Understanding the Madras High Court's stance on statutory bail under the BNSS and NDPS Act
Why incomplete investigative material does not invalidate a timely police report for default bail
By Legal Editor
New Delhi: November 15, 2026:
In a significant legal development regarding criminal jurisprudence and statutory rights under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), the Madras High Court (Madurai Bench) has delivered a clear verdict on default bail. The Court held that an accused person cannot claim statutory or default bail under Section 187(3) of the BNSS merely by treating a police report as "incomplete" because specific corroborative materials—such as CCTV footage or Call Detail Records (CDR)—are still pending retrieval or investigation.
This comprehensive news and legal analysis report explores the background of the case, the core legal arguments, statutory provisions under the BNSS, and the implications of this ruling for criminal trials across India.
Case Background: M. Alex v. Union of India
The matter arose from Crl. R.C.(MD) No. 1153 of 2026 before a bench comprising Mr. Justice B. Murugesan.
- The Incident: The revision petitioner (Accused No. 1, M. Alex) was arrested on April 14, 2025, by the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB), Chennai Zonal Unit. He was implicated under the Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985, after being allegedly found in possession of 950 grams of Methamphetamine.
- Filing of the Police Report: The NCB filed its police report (chargesheet) before the Special Court for EC and NDPS Act Cases at Pudukkottai well within the statutory window on October 3, 2025 (registered as C.C. No. 258 of 2025).
- The Petition for Default Bail: The accused subsequently filed a criminal miscellaneous petition seeking default/statutory bail under Section 187(3) BNSS. His primary contention was that the police report was "incomplete" because crucial evidence—specifically, CCTV footage from a toll plaza (ordered to be retrieved by the Central Forensic Science Laboratory, Hyderabad) and CDR/CAF details of a mobile phone used in the alleged conspiracy—had not yet been fully compiled or annexed.
- The Lower Court's Ruling: The Special Court dismissed the petition on May 26, 2026, prompting the petitioner to approach the Madras High Court via a criminal revision petition.
Core Legal Issue Examined by the Court
The central question before the High Court was:
Whether a police report filed within the statutory time period can be deemed an "incomplete police report" entitling the accused to statutory bail under Section 187(3) BNSS simply because certain auxiliary electronic evidence, forensic data, or call records are still pending completion or retrieval?
Key Legal Findings and Analysis
1. Completeness of a Police Report under the BNSS
The Court analyzed the provisions of the BNSS—specifically Sections 189, 190, and 193 (akin to Sections 167, 170, and 173 of the erstwhile Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973).
- Sufficiency vs. Exhaustiveness: The Court reiterated that a positive police report is legally complete if it contains sufficient evidence or reasonable grounds of suspicion enabling a Magistrate to take cognizance of the offense.
- Directory vs. Mandatory Nature: Relying on settled precedents, including the Supreme Court rulings in CBI v. R.S. Pai and the recent 2026 judgment in Shaurya Sunil Singh v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2026 INSC 666), the Court noted that while all documents should normally accompany a chargesheet, minor omissions or pending ancillary reports do not vitiate the report or render it "incomplete" in the eyes of the law.
2. Extinguishment of Default Bail Rights
The Madras High Court emphasized that the right to default bail is an indefeasible right tied to personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. However, this right is conditional upon the non-filing of the chargesheet within the prescribed 60- or 90-day window.
Once a valid police report is filed within the stipulated period and the court takes cognizance of the offense, the right to statutory bail ceases entirely. Any subsequent or pending investigation (such as forensic retrieval of electronic devices) falls under the domain of further investigation permitted under Section 193(9) of the BNSS and does not revive the right to default bail.
3. The Role of the Accused in Investigation
Addressing the petitioner's argument that the investigating agency was bound to collect and file specific exculpatory material (like toll plaza CCTV footage) before submitting the report, the Court reaffirmed the principle laid down in Union of India v. W.N. Chadha:
- An accused person has no right to dictate the manner and method of investigation.
- The accused cannot claim a statutory default bail right by demanding that specific pieces of evidence must first be secured by the police to make a chargesheet "complete."
Final Verdict and Directions
The Madras High Court dismissed the criminal revision petition, upholding the Special Court’s order denying statutory bail. Furthermore, considering the prolonged nature of the proceedings, the High Court directed the Special Court to expedite and complete the trial in C.C. No. 258 of 2025 within a period of two months from the receipt of the order.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is "default bail" or "statutory bail" under the BNSS?
Default bail is a statutory right granted to an accused person under Section 187(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) if the investigating agency fails to file a chargesheet (police report) within the prescribed time period (typically 60 or 90 days depending on the gravity of the offense).
2. Can an accused claim default bail if the chargesheet lacks CCTV footage or call records?
No. As per this Madras High Court ruling, as long as the police report is filed within the statutory period containing sufficient material for the court to take cognizance, the absence of pending forensic reports, CCTV footage, or call detail records (CDR) does not make the chargesheet "incomplete" for the purpose of default bail.
3. What happens if the police want to collect more evidence after filing the chargesheet?
Under Section 193(9) of the BNSS, the investigating agency is legally permitted to conduct further investigation and file supplementary reports if additional oral or documentary evidence comes to light later.
4. Does the accused have a say in how a criminal investigation is conducted?
No. Indian jurisprudence firmly establishes that an accused person does not have the right to direct or interfere with the manner, method, or pace of an ongoing police investigation.
5. Which laws and courts were involved in this specific ruling?
The case involved Crl. R.C.(MD) No. 1153 of 2026 heard by the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court (Justice B. Murugesan), concerning an NDPS Act case investigated by the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) under the newly enacted BNSS framework.
Related articles
Default BailJammu and Kashmir High Court Denies Default Bail to Three Accused in Kathua Terror Case: A Comprehensive Legal Analysis
This article delves into the Jammu and Kashmir High Court's ruling denying default bail to three accused in the Kathua Terror case, analyzing the statutory implications under UAPA and broader counter-terrorism laws.
7 min read
Default BailJ&K&L High Court Denies Default Bail to UAPA Accused: Charge-Sheet Filed Within 180 Days Extinguishes Right to Statutory Bail
The Jammu and Kashmir High Court ruled that the right to default bail under the UAPA is extinguished if the charge-sheet is filed within 180 days, highlighting significant legal implications for accused individuals.
8 min read