Calcutta High Court Denies Bail to Howrah ISIS Accused, Rules Alleged Suicide Squad Recruitment Crosses Threshold of 'Overt Acts'
The Calcutta High Court has denied bail to Saddam Mallick, citing clear evidence of active terror recruitment and foreign handler links under UAPA.
- By
- BailNow Research Team
- Published
- Reading time
- 5 min read

Finding clear prima facie evidence of active terror radicalisation and foreign handler links, the Calcutta High Court dismisses Saddam Mallick's bail appeal and rejects his claim of prosecution-induced trial delay.
By Legal Reporter
KOLKATA, November 13, 2026: In a consequential ruling reinforcing the strict bail threshold under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), the Calcutta High Court on November 13, 2026, rejected the bail plea of 28-year-old Howrah resident Md. Saddam alias Saddam Mallick alias Abdul Mallick. A division bench comprising Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray dismissed his appeal (CRA (DB) 324 of 2025), concluding that forensic evidence extracted from his digital devices points to active terror recruitment rather than passive ideological sympathy.
Arrested initially by the Kolkata Police Special Task Force (STF) on January 6, 2023—with the National Investigation Agency (NIA) subsequently taking over the probe—Mallick has spent three years and ten months in judicial custody. The court’s order draws a sharp legal line between mere possession of extremist propaganda and actionable participation in radicalisation networks.
Digital Forensics and the 'Overt Act' Threshold Under UAPA
A central pillar of the defence’s argument rested on settled constitutional jurisprudence that merely possessing jihadi literature or disturbing videos on personal devices does not constitute a terrorist act under UAPA without proof of an "overt act." However, the division bench found that the NIA’s forensic extraction reports established a prima facie case that went far beyond passive consumption.
According to submissions placed on record by the NIA, investigators recovered videos detailing assassination plots targeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi and US President Donald Trump, alongside graphic footage of beheadings. More critically, digital trails allegedly showed Mallick administering clandestine Telegram groups designed to radicalise local youth, instigate them to join a "suicide squad," and facilitate travel to Afghanistan and the Khorasan region for terrorist training. Forensic records also flagged cross-border communications with handlers and entities operating out of Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Syria.
The bench also dismantled the defence’s parity argument regarding a key prosecution witness, Farhan, on whose phone similar extremist material was found. The court observed that Farhan was a student who had come to Howrah for his studies, and investigators found that Mallick had systematically transmitted the propaganda to indoctrinate him. Because the alleged recruiter and the target of radicalisation do not stand on the same legal footing, the court ruled that Farhan’s status as a protected witness offered no grounds for Mallick’s release.
Trial Delay Defence Rejected: When Accused's Own Pleas Halt Proceedings
Mallick’s legal team also sought bail on the grounds of prolonged incarceration and slow trial progress, citing the Supreme Court’s landmark K.A. Najeeb precedent, which allows constitutional courts to grant bail under Article 21 when a UAPA trial faces indefinite delay. Out of 52 witnesses listed in the NIA’s July 4, 2023, chargesheet, only three had been examined since charges were formally framed on August 14, 2025.
Analysing the procedural timeline, the Calcutta High Court refused to attribute this bottleneck to the prosecuting agency. The bench noted that Mallick had filed a discharge application before the trial court—a statutory right, yet one that predictably stalled witness examination while the trial judge adjudicated and ultimately dismissed the plea. Holding that the prosecution displayed no intentional laches and that the custody period had not reached the "melting point" envisioned in K.A. Najeeb, the judges concluded that national security concerns outweighed the plea for bail at this stage.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why did the Calcutta High Court deny bail to Saddam Mallick? The division bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray held that digital forensic evidence showed prima facie "overt acts" under Section 43D (5) of UAPA, including running encrypted Telegram groups, instigating youth to join a suicide squad, and communicating with foreign handlers, rather than mere possession of extremist material.
2. Who is investigating the Howrah ISIS module case? While the Kolkata Police Special Task Force (STF) made the initial arrests on January 6, 2023, the Union Ministry of Home Affairs transferred the investigation to the National Investigation Agency (NIA), which re-registered the case as RC-01/2023/NIA/DLI.
3. Why did the court reject the argument of prolonged trial delay? Although only three of 52 chargesheet witnesses had been examined, the High Court noted that the trial was halted primarily because the accused filed a discharge application. Since the prosecution was not at fault for the delay, the court ruled the K.A. Najeeb bail exception did not apply.
4. Why was witness Farhan granted protection despite having similar videos on his phone? The court clarified that Farhan was a student whom Mallick allegedly targeted for indoctrination by sending extremist material to his device, placing the recruiter and the recruit on entirely different legal footings.
Related articles
UAPA BailBail Cannot Be Undone by Transit Detention: Kerala High Court Tells FRRO to Consider Rented Home for UAPA Accused
The Kerala High Court ruled that bail cannot be negated by transit detention, allowing a UAPA accused to reside in a rented home instead of a transit facility, emphasizing the importance of personal liberty.
5 min read
UAPA Bail2023 Parliament Security Breach: Delhi Court Denies Bail to Key Accused, Citing Prima Facie UAPA Case
The Delhi Court has denied bail to the main accused in the 2023 Parliament security breach, emphasizing the prima facie UAPA charges against them. This ruling highlights key legal principles surrounding terrorism laws in India.
5 min read